Showing posts with label legal tips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label legal tips. Show all posts

Monday, November 25, 2013

If you breach a contract, it is unlikely that you can simply walk away.

You should not sign a contract unless you are prepared to complete it, even if you encounter unforeseen circumstances. Things happen; people lose their job, die, and get sick. But if you sign a contract, you consent to the possibility of a lawsuit or arbitration to enforce its terms. It is common for people to sign an agreement without reviewing it, or to think they can rescind their acceptance after signing.

If you sign a contract but do not complete it, you may be forced to perform (specific performance). You may be forced to pay the other party the money it spent in relying on your completion of the contract  (reliance damages). Or you may be required to pay the other party the amount it would have received if you completed the contract without breaching it (expectation damages).

Expecting people to read the entire terms and conditions of every contract they sign is probably impractical. But every time you sign your name in exchange for something of value, you should consider what the contract requires. If you breach the contract's terms, it is highly unlikely that you can simply walk away.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

The general prohibition on hearsay increases the importance of getting things in writing.

Tangible evidence is really important. Get things in writing when you can. If you are in a legal dispute, third parties typically do not want to get involved. This is true even though you can require them to testify with a subpoena. If you think a third party said something to support your case, they may not remember it that way. They may remember it differently, or not at all. This is common.

The general prohibition on hearsay compounds the importance of getting tangible evidence. The simplest definition of hearsay is that it is something someone else said, offered into evidence. There are some exceptions, but you can rarely testify to what someone else said.

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

In a lawsuit, time is often your best friend.

If you get in a legal dispute, the hardest thing to do is wait. You want the situation resolved immediately, and it is understandable why. Litigation is very stressful. That being said, the best thing for your case is often the elapse of time. It takes time for the truth to work itself out.

For example, let's say you file a lawsuit. The defendant answers your complaint with a version of events inapposite with yours. This is standard, but it stresses you out. Through discovery requests, depositions and nonlegal factors like the defendant's economic situation, the truth will come out. It just takes time.

Where a lawsuit involves preliminary injunctive relief, or in a business dispute with multiple and varied economic considerations, a "rocket docket"may be preferable. Otherwise, time is usually your friend.

Friday, November 1, 2013

The power of the affidavit, even in everyday life.

An affidavit is submitted in state court. A declaration is submitted in federal court, but they are the same thing. They are sworn testimony, subject to the penalty of perjury. Both support a plaintiff or defendant's position. The person who signed the affidavit [or declaration] must testify consistently in a courtroom with what the written testimony in the affidavit says.

An affidavit does not need to be submitted in connection with a lawsuit. It can be submitted independently of a lawsuit to give more credibility to someone's position. For instance, let's say you are in a dispute with a company over one of its products, and you claim the product is defective. The company is skeptical about your claim, and thinks you may have caused the defect. To support your position, you could offer to submit an affidavit stating that you did not cause the defect and it was present when you purchased the product. This adds immense credibility to your position, because this is what you would say if the issue found its way into court. And as the affidavit would say, if you are lying, you could get into a lot of trouble.

Conversely, if you own a company and are skeptical about a customer's claim, ask them to submit an affidavit with their version of events. If they are reticent, they may not be telling the truth, although it is possible they just do not understand what an affidavit is. If they do not have an issue with it, it suggests that they may be telling the truth.

An affidavit is simply the adult version of a kid telling another kid, "I swear on ________'s life, that this is true." Contrary to popular belief, an affidavit does not always to have to be notarized. In many jurisdictions, including federal court, it only needs to include language like the following above the signature: "I certify under penalty of perjury and pursuant to the laws of the state of ______, that the foregoing is true and correct."

Monday, August 5, 2013

Teaching basic legal analysis through college football.

Applying the rules of college football to in-game situations is like applying the law to legal disputes. The same process is used: abstraction, which is the application of written rules or laws to new and unique situations. American law is largely statutory. This is similar to the rules of college football, which are entirely based on a written rule book.

In legal situations, a client or prospective client comes to an attorney's office with a story. The attorney identifies the issues in the story and figures out the best way to proceed. For a situation to fit within a particular law or theory, specific criteria must be met. This is similar to college football. If you see a player break a rule, you must identify the infraction and apply the correct rule and penalty. With both, you cannot simply throw a flag when you see wrongdoing without knowing exactly what rule or law to apply.

Referees in football are like judges in the law. They are the arbiter of infractions. The coaches are like lawyers, arguing for their own particular interpretation of the rules. To illustrate abstraction of college football rules to in-game situations, watch this video from the 2013 Sugar Bowl. Here, the University of Louisville quarterback is hit by a defensive player from the University of Florida. The penalty called was "roughing the passer." Roughing the passer occurs when a defensive player "charge[s] into a passer or throw[s] him to the ground when it is obvious the ball has been thrown." Clearly, the correct call was made in this situation, because it was obvious that the Louisville quarterback threw the ball immediately before he was hit.

Here's another one to try. Is the running back a "defenseless player"? A defenseless player is "one who because of his physical condition and focus of concentration is especially vulnerable to injury." The definition provides examples of a defenseless player:

  • A player in the act of or just after throwing a pass.
  • A receiver attempting to catch a pass, or one who has completed a catch and has not had time to protect himself or has not clearly become a ball carrier.
  • A kicker in the act of or just after kicking a ball, or during the kick or the return.
  • A kick returner attempting to catch or recover a kick.
  • A player on the ground.
  • A player obviously out of the play.
  • A player who receives a blind-side block.
  • A ball carrier already in the grasp of an opponent and whose forward progress has been stopped.
  • A quarterback any time after a change of possession.

The running back was a defenseless player. The examples provided in the definition were not limited only to those situations. Referees have discretion in determining whether a player is defenseless or not. The running back's focus was on taking the ball from the quarterback. He was vulnerable to injury, because he could not protect himself. Accordingly, he was a "defenseless player."

Applying the law to a particular situation is rarely this easy, and is often much more complex. Nevertheless, abstraction is used in both the law and college football.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

Little things you can do to help yourself from a legal perspective.

There are basically three types of clients: Prepared clients; moderately prepared clients, and clients who are so unprepared that it is prejudicial to their case. Most people and businesses fall within the middle category: Moderately prepared. However, if you can make yourself a prepared client, you have already gone a long way toward helping yourself in a legal dispute.

Lawyers work on facts. The more facts, the better the lawyer can differentiate between meaningful facts and meaningless ones. With meaningful facts, the lawyer can fit them into one or more legal theories on which to base a case.

The difference between being a prepared, moderately prepared or unprepared client is not stark. There are a few simple precepts or principles that people and businesses can implement into their daily lives that will dramatically help them in the event of future litigation. These should begin before legal disputes can be foreseen, not at the 11th hour.

Attorneys have difficulty representing clients when they are unclear about facts and a sequence of events. The lawyer's ability to "think outside the box" regarding finding solutions to issues depends on his or her ability to know as much as he or she can about the facts of a particular issue, and the legal theories into which the lawyer can fit those facts. So here are a few simple things that you can do to help yourself in the event of unforeseeable future litigation:

1. Do not post information or comments about legal disputes on social media.

You would be surprised at how much this edict is violated. People get emotional and lose their better judgment. They post information on a social media site, which is discoverable information. In most cases, the other person in the dispute is watching your social media accounts to see if you say something incriminating. If you do, they will take a screen shot and include that information in their evidence.

Information here includes pictures, which can directly contradict what someone is claiming. For instance, in workers' compensation cases, it is not uncommon to see the person claiming the disability post pictures of waterskiing on Facebook, or doing something else that stops their claim dead in its tracks. The Internet does not forget, and in a dispute, people are watching you as closely as you are watching them.

2. Watch what you say.

It is very easy to meet the technical legal definition of business interference, which can also be known as interference with business relations. It is really, really easy to meet the technical legal definition of defamation. Now, an element to recovery of monies in legal disputes is damages, which is what value of detriment the plaintiff suffered in a suit. So, meeting the technical definition of business interference and defamation does not mean that you would have to pay a lot of money to a plaintiff, but it does mean that in theory, you could have a judgment of business interference or defamation on your record.

Basically, do not spread gossip damaging another person's reputation, and do not try to break up business relationships.

3. Keep records and journals of important and mundane events.

One of the best ways you can help your attorney is to save emails, calendars, and have a timeline of events in a legal dispute. It will save you money in the long run, because the attorney will not have to do as much work in finding information, and it drastically improves your chances of winning. As a client, you do not have to know the law or all the relevant facts of a legal theory. But if you can provide your attorney with the information he or she ideally needs, it can be all the difference in your case.

With today's technology, it is not that difficult. Just do not delete old events off of your calendar, because even unrelated events can rekindle the memory of a forgotten event. In a perfect world, a client will record all of their daily events, but this is not practicable. Just save information, archive emails and keep record of meetings and events.

4. Get things in writing.

Clients regularly think that evidence is easier to obtain than it is. Unfortunately, people lie. People do not want to get involved in the legal process as a witness. People forget. Also, clients retrospectively infer the meaning behind certain statements in their favor. When a client claims that someone said such-and-such, and it purportedly supports the client's position, the other conversant often did not mean what the client thinks he or she meant. It is human nature to look for things in your favor, but it is not always consistent with reality.

Although one can be prosecuted for perjury, rarely does a case go by that someone does not lie on the stand. Maybe they did not even intentionally do so, but they have told themselves a story so many times that they believe it. It is just as George Costanza said, "it is not a lie if you believe it." People always think of themselves as the protagonist, and will unconsciously manipulate stories to make themselves the "good guy." So when a client comes in thinking that a case is cut-and-dry, they are surprised to find out that their opponent's story has changed from what they expected.

So, people forget, lie, and generally try to avoid having to be a fact witness in a case. If you can get something in writing, you drastically improve your chance of success in a dispute.

5. When a dispute arises (long before the institution of the legal process), the less you say is better. This includes in text messages, social media and emails.

Before a lawsuit is filed, or attorneys are consulted, it is prudent to self-impose a gag order when discussing the subject with others. This does not include spouses, who are generally privileged from divulging confidential marital communications. But if you text message someone, or tweet something -- even if it is not directly about the person -- it is discoverable information. This dovetails with my first point, but I cannot stress it enough. If it is recorded, digitally or otherwise, it usually can be admitted as evidence.