Showing posts with label sports law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sports law. Show all posts

Thursday, March 27, 2014

Why was the National Labor Relations Board’s ruling that college athletes can unionize limited to private institutions?


Under the National Labor Relations Act, states are not "employers." Since public schools are part of their state government, public schools are not employers under the NLRA. Since private schools are not part of their state government, they are not employers under the NLRA. The federal regulations of the NLRB explicitly provide that the NLRB will exercise jurisdictions over issues involving private nonprofit colleges and universities that have a gross annual revenue of $1M or more.

This does not mean that college athletes at public schools cannot unionize, it just means they have to do so differently. Those athletes would have to unionize under procedures for public sector employees. Some states are right to work states, which prevents compulsory union participation for public sector employees. Those employees could join the union if they wanted to do so, but they would not have to join or participate in its labor policies or goals.

On the other hand, Northwestern's college athletes will be voting within the month to determine whether they will be represented by the College Athletes Players Association. The CAPA was just recently formed. If a majority of Northwestern's athletes vote for representation, then all Northwestern athletes will be represented by the CAPA.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

On the negligence lawsuit involving former Iowa football players injured during the rhabdomyolysis exercise scandal in January 2011.

In January 2011, 13 football players for the University of Iowa were hospitalized with rhabdomyolysis, which is the breakdown of muscle tissue leading to the release of muscle fiber contents into the bloodstream. The players suffered this condition as the result of overly strenuous workouts following a disappointing 2010 football season.

On March 10, 2014, one former player injured by "rhabdo" sued the school and State of Iowa for negligence. Unless one or more of the injured former players were in negotiation with the school before January 2013, and unless the parties agreed to waive arguments based on Iowa's statute of limitations, the player or players may lose on a technicality. Iowa Code 614.1(2) provides that personal injury lawsuits must be brought within two years. The former player's claim was initiated more than three years after the injury. Accordingly, even though the school would likely be liable for negligence, it may win because the player waited too long to file the lawsuit. That said, it is more likely that the players were previously in confidential negotiation with the school, and the parties agreed to waive any argument based on the statute of limitations.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Iowa head football coach Kirk Ferentz likely has a defamation claim against a former player.

Embattled former University of Iowa wide receiver Derrell Johnson-Koulianos (a/k/a "DJK") went on a recent Twitter rant leveling defamatory allegations against his old coach and current Iowa head football coach, Kirk Ferentz. DJK got in plenty of trouble at Iowa, and was kicked off the team in 2010 after a drug arrest. He never played again for the school, did not play in the NFL, and was unsuccessful in tryouts with the Arena Football and Canadian Football Leagues.

DJK alleges that Ferentz once required DJK to wear a trash can on his head during a practice, and was responsible for arranging the drug arrest that resulted in DJK's removal from the football team. DJK claims that all of this will be included in a book to be released in Iowa and Ohio in 2014, but no book deal has been arranged.

For a public figure to have a viable claim for defamation, the defendant must have said or written a false and defamatory statement of fact about a third person, with recklessness or malice, and no First Amendment privilege to do so. DJK's assertions are statements of fact that are likely false. If they are true, Ferentz has no claim, but DJK's veracity has been shown to be less than reliable in the past.

The statements were published via Twitter, and appear to have been published for the sole purpose of damaging Ferentz's reputation. If Ferentz can show he suffered damages because of the statements, which will not be easy, he has a viable defamation claim against DJK.

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

On the new concussion class action lawsuit against the NHL.

Concussion lawsuits against sports organizations are in vogue. The NFL recently settled a class action lawsuit for $765M. The NCAA is currently facing one. Now, former NHL players filed a class action complaint against the NHL. The number of plaintiffs started at 10, but has grown to more than 200. All of the concussion lawsuits center around a condition called Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE). The NHL players' suit alleges the same culpable conduct on the NHL's part as the former NFL players' suit alleged against the NFL: that the league withheld information and research on the effects of repeated head trauma.

With the NHL suit, it is pretty simple. If the NHL withheld information from the players, then it will likely be found liable or will pay a lot of money in settling. The opposite is not true. If the NHL does settle for a lot of money, it does not necessarily mean that it would be found liable if the case went to trial. When the NFL settled its class action, it admitted no liability.

The players will still need to file a motion for class certification. At this point, they just filed the class action complaint, which leaves the door open for class certification. Individual federal district courts set their own rules regarding deadlines for class certification.

Friday, October 25, 2013

No surprise: NCAA's motion to dismiss student-athlete likeness antitrust lawsuit was denied.

It is no surprise that the NCAA's motion to dismiss the student-athlete likeness antitrust lawsuit was denied. The NCAA is the lone remaining defendant; all others have settled. The NCAA's attorneys who filed the motion could be sanctioned by the court, because there was no chance the motion would be granted and they filed it anyway.

If an attorney files a document in a lawsuit for an improper purpose like harassment or to needlessly increase the cost of litigation, the court can sanction the attorney who filed it. As you would expect, an attorney who files a motion for sanctions raises the personal stakes of everyone involved.

Thursday, October 24, 2013

Aggravating and mitigating circumstances in NCAA enforcement.

In addition to lacking subpoena power and legal standards, the presence or absence of aggravating and mitigating circumstances affects the penalties levied in NCAA infractions cases.

Aggravating circumstances warrant the imposition of more severe penalties in an infractions case. Mitigating circumstances warrant the imposition of less severe penalties in a case. Aggravating circumstances include but are not limited to an institution's history, and the school's cooperation with the NCAA during an investigation. If you fail to cooperate or try to conceal violations, you are subject to more severe penalties. Conversely, if you exhibit exemplary cooperation or have little to history of rules violations, you may be given less severe penalties.

It may seem axiomatic that cooperation mitigates potential penalties in an infractions case, but without subpoena power the NCAA must put a premium on openness. Otherwise, it would be extremely difficult for the NCAA to discover relevant information in a given case, because there would no incentive for schools to do so.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

If fired for the 2011 audio tape, Nebraska football coach Bo Pelini has a claim for business interference.

In October 2011, University of Nebraska head football coach Bo Pelini delivered a post-game press conference shortly after his team completed the biggest comeback in school history. Nebraska had just defeated Ohio State, 34-27, after being down 21 points in the second half. In an off-the-record conversation prior to the press-conference, Pelini lambasted the fans who left the game early, and journalists from the Omaha newspaper. Pelini's comments included numerous instances of the "f-word." They were ill-advised, and some people are understandably offended.

Basically, Pelini called Nebraska fans "fair-weather," which is completely untrue. If there is any fan-base that is not "fair-weather," it is Nebraska football fans. The team has been mostly successful for the last 50 years, but it has also sold out every home game since 1962. No other school comes remotely close. Even in down years, the fans still show up for games. The anger toward the journalists was for leaving press conferences early.


Surely, Pelini's contract has a "morals clause" that might justify dismissal for those type of comments. But even if the school has cause for firing Pelini, the person who released the tape does not have the right to release the tape for the purpose of getting Pelini fired.

If the audio tape had been released shortly after the tirade occurred, there would not necessarily be a claim, because the motives of the person who released the tape would not be so clear. But two years after the fact and after a bad loss at home, the person's motives could not be clearer. The person wanted Pelini fired, and any jury could see this. Business interference requires:

(1) a contract;
(2) that a defendant has knowledge of the contract;
(3) that the defendant intentionally and improperly interfered with the contract;
(4) the interference caused the third party not to perform or to stop performing the contract; and
(5) that the plaintiff was damaged.

The person who released the tape surely knew that Pelini has a contract with the school. Releasing the tape to get the coach fired constitutes "improper interference." If Pelini is fired, he could recover the amount he would earn if there had not been improper interference, i.e., if the tape had not been released for the purpose of getting him fired. He could not recover that amount from the school, but from the person who released the tape. Accordingly, the person who released the tape could be liable for millions of dollars of actual damages, as well as punitive damages if his or her conduct is deemed particularly willful and wanton.

Whether Pelini can recover depends on if he loses his job due to the audio tape. In another post, I warned readers of the ease with which you can be guilty of business interference.

Monday, September 16, 2013

The "Johnny Football" trademark could get sacked.

I have written about Johnny Manziel's "Johnny Football" nickname/mark several times:

- The conflict between U.S. trademark law and NCAA rules: The "Johnny Football" scenario.
- On trademark infringement.
- Use of a trademark "in commerce" and the redux of the Johnny Football example.
- Agency, Cam Newton and Johnny Manziel -- Part 2: Teaching basic legal analysis through college football.
- What is the NCAA enforcement team looking at when investigating Johnny Manziel's eligibility? Part 3: Teaching basic legal analysis through college football.
- By definition, a college athlete with a federally registered trademark is violating NCAA rules.
- Illustrating the difference in legal standards through the NCAA and Johnny Football autograph situation.

Manziel is unique among college athletes because the NCAA allowed him to protect his "Johnny Football" mark prior to the expiration of his eligibility. Being able to protect his mark does not mean that he can use the mark in commerce. If he did use the mark in commerce, he would be violating NCAA rules.

The United States Patent and Trademark Office recently issued an office action illustrating its concern that the "Johnny Football" mark is not being used as a trademark. Manziel is in a difficult position, because he cannot use the mark in commerce and maintain eligibility. But he must use the mark in commerce to obtain a valid federal registration. Manziel's people made a big mistake by not pursuing an intent-to-use application followed by affidavit of use once his eligibility expires. That would have solved this problem.

Friday, September 6, 2013

Opting out of a class action: The NFL publicity rights example.

As discussed previously, class certification is required before a case is a class action. If a case settles after class certification, court approval is needed before the case can be dismissed. Class members who object to terms of any settlement can opt out of the class. If a class member opts out, he or she is not precluded from bringing another suit against the defendant. If a class member does not opt out, he or she is precluded from bringing another suit against the defendant (unless new facts or events are involved).

This happened in a case filed August 30, 2013. The plaintiffs are former NFL players, and they opted out of a previous class action, Dryer v. NFL. The plaintiffs argue that the NFL and NFL Films used their likenesses without compensation or their consent, like the plaintiffs are arguing in the NCAA student-athlete likeness antitrust litigation. Before approving a class action settlement, a court must make sure five requirements have been met:

- Reasonable notice must be directed to all class members bound by the proposed settlement;
- If the proposed settlement binds class members (which it usually would), the court can approve it only after a fair and adequate hearing on the settlement;
- The parties seeking approval of the proposed settlement must file a statement identifying the terms of any agreement;
- Any class member has a right to object; and
- The court can refuse to approve the settlement if a second opportunity for class members to opt out is not afforded, even if those class members previously had an opportunity to opt out.

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Former NFL star Jim Brown made a strategic error in suit against EA Sports.

NFL hall-of-famer Jim Brown lost a recent appeal against EA Sports, in which Brown alleged that EA Sports used his likeness in the Madden series of video games without his consent. EA Sports is also a defendant in the NCAA student-athlete likeness antitrust litigation, and there are similarities between the two cases. The plaintiffs in the NCAA student-athlete likeness antitrust litigation alleged that their likenesses were used in video games without their consent. In the NCAA and NFL video games, names were not used, but other aspects of the players were imitated. The video game players shared the same jersey number, size, physical skills, skin color and other attributes with their real-life counterparts.

The names of most players are used in the Madden series of video games, because they are licensed by the NFL players' union (NFLPA). Player names that were not licensed by the NFLPA were not included in the game unless consent was given. There is no college football players' union, so no player names were used in the NCAA Football video game.

Brown made a strategic error in his lawsuit. The student-athletes' lawsuit alleged that the use of their likenesses was an antitrust violation. Brown alleged that the use of his likeness was a violation of federal trademark law, which was largely inapplicable to his case.

If Brown sued under common law rights of publicity, his claim would have survived dismissal because a different legal analysis would have applied. Instead, EA Sports filed a motion to dismiss, which was granted and affirmed on appeal.

Basically, in addressing the claim under trademark law, the court only considered the publicity rights issue insofar as it pertained to a violation of trademark law. Since Jim Brown's likeness is not a federal trademark, trademark law was largely inapplicable in his case. Brown should have known of the pending NCAA student-athlete likeness antitrust litigation, and amended his complaint to include a publicity rights claim.

If Brown had done this, when the trademark claim was dismissed, he could have still litigated the publicity rights claim. Since he did not, and the dismissal has now been granted, he is precluded from bringing the publicity rights issue in a new lawsuit.

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Illustrating the difference in legal standards through the NCAA and Johnny Football autograph situation.

- Do we know that Johnny Manziel took money for autographs by a preponderance of the evidence? In other words, is it more likely than not that Manziel took money for autographs?
- Do we have clear and convincing evidence that Manziel took money for autographs?
- Is there reasonable doubt whether Manziel took money for autographs?

One of the biggest differences between the American judicial system and NCAA enforcement is the former's use of legal standards. The legal standards in the United States are: (1) proof by a preponderance of the evidence; (2) proof by clear and convincing evidence; and (3) proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

For a plaintiff to win in a civil case, proof by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not) is usually required. In some cases, such as juvenile or family law, proof is required by clear and convincing evidence. Only in criminal law is proof required beyond a reasonable doubt.

The NCAA enforcement bylaws provide no legal standards for guidance. As a result, lawyers for big-money schools can exonerate student-athletes alleged of wrongdoing as long as the student-athletes deal in cash. It is really that simple: If you deal in cash, it does not matter how brazen the violations are. If you are a big enough school with enough money, you can buy your way out of trouble. The NCAA is complicit in the alleged wrongdoing, because it tries to protect its economic interests in handing out penalties. The NCAA will rarely penalize an athlete if it can make money from him or her.

The rule prohibiting Manziel from signing autographs for money should be changed. He should be able to sign autographs and retain eligibility, just like Olympic athletes can sign autographs for money but still compete in the Olympics. But current NCAA rules prohibit signing for money, and Manziel should have abided by those rules. He was not forced to play college football.

Manziel allegedly signed thousands of autographs. The NCAA's rationale in not penalizing him was that it could not prove that Manziel took money for autographs? By what standard?

It is much more likely than not that Manziel took money for autographs. There is also very likely clear and convincing evidence that he did. This is without subpoena power, which the NCAA lacks. Witnesses said he took money. There are thousands of Manziel-signed items available. There is a picture of him signing autographs in a seedy hotel room with people he did not know. He admittedly hates signing autographs. Also, there is allegedly an audio recording where Manziel basically admits to receiving payment for the autographs.

There might not even be reasonable doubt whether Manziel took money for autographs. It would be for a jury to decide. Public opinion certainly suggests that there is no reasonable doubt, although it is sometimes difficult to determine exactly how much evidence the NCAA could use. Anonymous sources cannot be used. This is analogous to the criminal justice system where a defendant has the right to face his or her accuser.

Despite evidentiary limitations, there is no reason Manziel should not have been penalized. The NCAA even changed its definition of "agent" in January 2012 after the Cam Newton situation, which should have applied here. Manziel's handler allegedly told people that Manziel would not sign autographs for free. The NCAA could have penalized Manziel even without proving he accepted money. It did not do so.

We can be thankful that the American judicial system is more impartial than the NCAA's enforcement process.

Monday, August 26, 2013

Former football players' concussion lawsuit against the NCAA.

The student-athlete likeness antitrust litigation is not the only high-stakes case the NCAA is facing. In July 2013, the plaintiffs in a concussion lawsuit against the NCAA filed a motion for class certification. The requirements for class certification have been discussed in another post.

The concussion lawsuit is under a stay (which essentially means a timeout), because the parties are hoping to settle. Simply filing a motion for class certification before a stay gives the plaintiffs leverage, because it provides the NCAA incentive to settle. If the NCAA does not settle while under a stay and the plaintiffs' motion for class certification is later granted, then the NCAA is in a much worse position for settlement. If the NCAA does not settle while under a stay but the plaintiffs' motion for class certification is denied, the NCAA is not really in any better position than before the ruling on class certification.

Monday, August 19, 2013

A possible breach of contract action arising out of the dispute between the New York Yankees and Alex Rodriguez.

Recently, New York Yankees' third baseman Alex Rodriguez was suspended for 211 games by Major League Baseball (MLB) for performance-enhancing drug use. Rodriguez appealed, but the appeal is not likely to be decided until after the 2013 season. The suspension was not due to a failed drug test, but due to records and statements provided by a performance-enhancing drug distributor.

Rodriguez alleged that the Yankees worked with MLB to suspend him, because the team wanted a reason to void the remainder of Rodriguez's contract. Rodriguez recently returned from injury. He is aging and arguably not producing at the level the Yankees are obligated to pay him. Per Rodriguez,
"[W]hen . . . people are finding creative ways to cancel your contract, I think that's concerning for me. . . . "
The Yankees denied the allegations. I would not be surprised if this ends up in litigation, even if it is not the most likely scenario. If the 211-game suspension is upheld on appeal, the Yankees may be able to avoid full payment on Rodriguez's contract. If Rodriguez's allegations of collusion between the Yankees and MLB are true, he would have a breach of contract action against the Yankees.

The obligation of good faith and fair dealing is implicit in a contract. If a party enters into a contract and later engages in subterfuge to impede the contract's function, it is a breach of contract. In other words, if the Yankees contract with a player, they cannot secretly sabotage the player to avoid making payment on the contract.

Rodriguez's contract likely has a choice of law provision (preference for New York law). It may also have an agreement to arbitrate all disputes arising out of the contract. To prove a breach of contract, Rodriguez would have to show that he did what the contract required, and the Yankees breached the contract. If Rodriguez ends up suing, the Yankees would counterclaim for breach of contract. The Yankees would argue that Rodriguez's performance-enhancing drug use was a breach of the contract. As an affirmative defense to Rodriguez's claim, the Yankees would argue that Rodriguez's performance-enhancing drug use excused the team from having to fully perform the contract.

Friday, August 9, 2013

Challenging Major League Baseball's antitrust exemption: San Jose v. MLB.

Elsewhere, I discussed baseball's antitrust exemption:

- Why does Major League Baseball have an antitrust exemption?
- More on the antitrust exemption in baseball.
- An antitrust lawsuit against Minor League Baseball.

This is a good piece on a current lawsuit between the City of San Jose, California, and Major League Baseball. The City is challenging MLB's antitrust exemption, because it wants the MLB's Oakland Athletics to move to San Jose. MLB argues that stare decisis -- prior precedent or the status quo -- prevents the City from challenging the antitrust exemption. MLB also argues that the City does not have antitrust standing to bring suit, and allowing the City to do so would open the door for any city that wants a major league team to sue any major league organization.

Ultimately, more facts are needed to determine the merits of the City's case. Baseball's antitrust exemption will be overturned at some point in the future, but it is too early to tell if this is that point.